» » Female Circumcision: Multicultural Perspectives (Pennsylvania Studies in Human Rights)

Fb2 Female Circumcision: Multicultural Perspectives (Pennsylvania Studies in Human Rights) ePub

by Rogaia Mustafa Abusharaf

Category: Politics and Government
Subcategory: Political books
Author: Rogaia Mustafa Abusharaf
ISBN: 0812239245
ISBN13: 978-0812239249
Language: English
Publisher: University of Pennsylvania Press (February 2006)
Pages: 296
Fb2 eBook: 1108 kb
ePub eBook: 1918 kb
Digital formats: txt lrf azw mobi

Female Circumcision Multicultural Perspectives

Female Circumcision Multicultural Perspectives. 296 pages 6 x 9 2 illus. A provocative book, clearly written for both general and scholarly audiences. -American Ethnologist.

Female Circumcision book. Female Circumcision: Multicultural Perspectives. Start by marking Female Circumcision: Multicultural Perspectives as Want to Read: Want to Read savin. ant to Read.

Pennsylvania studies in human rights. Multicultural Perspectives. University of Pennsylvania Press.

Home Browse Books Book details, Female Circumcision . Rogaia Mustafa Abusharaf. I do not wish them to have power over men; but over themselves

Home Browse Books Book details, Female Circumcision: Multicultural Perspectives. By Rogaia Mustafa Abusharaf. Female Circumcision gathers together African activists to examine the issue within its various cultural and historical contexts, the debates on circumcision regarding African refugee and immigrant populations in the . and the human rights efforts to eradicate the practice. I do not wish them to have power over men; but over themselves. Mary Wollstonecraft, A Vindication of the Rights of Woman, 1792.

Multicultural Perspectives. Ed. by Abusharaf, Rogaia Mustafa. Series:Pennsylvania Studies in Human Rights. Rogaia Mustafa Abusharaf (2006). Chapter 1. Introduction: The Custom in Question. See all formats and pricing. Female Circumcision: Multicultural Perspectives (pp. 1–24). Online ISBN: 9780812201024.

Gender Violence Women Human rights Female genital cutting Feminism . In: Abursharaf Rogaia Mustafa (ed) Female Circumcision: Multicultural Perspectives. Abusharaf Rogaia Mustafa (2006) Female Circumcision.

Gender Violence Women Human rights Female genital cutting Feminism Africa Culture Colonialism. Abursharaf Rogaia Mustafa (2006) Introduction: The Custom in Question. University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia, PA, p 12Google Scholar. University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia, PAGoogle Scholar. Bunch Charlotte (1999) Women’s Rights as Human Rights. In: Savic Obrad (ed) The Politics of Human Rights.

NGOs’ Roles in Human Rights Protection Human rights NGOs vary widely in their goals, resources, and approaches, and they address monitoring and enforcement, as well as involvement in governmental and intergovernmental venues, in different ways and to varying degrees. 8 The tools NGOs have used to foster governmental respect for human rights include independent reporting, efforts to raise public awareness, direct appeals to governments, and the use of public opinion and expert advice to influence government officials through campaigns built around specific issues.

Female Genital Mutilation-A Human Rights Information

Female Genital Mutilation-A Human Rights Information. Retrieved September 17, 2004. The purpose of this study was to determine if there is a relationship between female circumcision and domestic violence. Circumcised women were more likely to support continuation of female circumcision, to circumcise their daughters, and to accept the right of husbands to beat their wives.

The Human Rights Studies MA is an interdisciplinary program that focuses on the academic study of human rights theory and practice. Students take courses offered by ISHR, as well as human rights courses offered by other departments, such as Anthropology, History, Political Science, Religion, and Sociology. Students may also take courses offered by other schools at Columbia, including the School of International and Public Affairs, Columbia Law School, and the Mailman School of Public Health.

Bolokoli, Khifad, tahara, tahoor, qudiin, irua, bondo, kuruna, negekorsigin, and kene-kene are a few of the terms used in local African languages to denote a set of cultural practices collectively known as female circumcision. Practiced in many countries across Africa and Asia, this ritual is hotly debated. Supporters regard it as a central coming-of-age ritual that ensures chastity and promotes fertility. Human rights groups denounce the procedure as barbaric. It is estimated that between 100 million and 130 million girls or women today have undergone forms of this genital surgery.

Female Circumcision gathers together African activists to examine the issue within its various cultural and historical contexts, the debates on circumcision regarding African refugee and immigrant populations in the U.S. and the human rights efforts to eradicate the practice. This work brings African women's voices into the discussion, foregrounds indigenous processes of social and cultural change, and demonstrates the manifold linkages between respect for women's bodily integrity, the empowerment of women, and the democratic modes of economic development.

This volume is one of the few attempts at systematic documentation of new perspectives on processes of change in diverse cultural and religious contexts. It does not focus narrowly on female circumcision as a set of ritualized surgeries sanctioned by society. Instead, the contributors explore a chain of connecting issues and processes through which the practice is being transformed in local and transnational contexts. Shifts in local views are fully explored to highlight processes of change, and this book chronicles the efforts of diverse communities as agents in the process of cultural and social transformation.

Comments to eBook Female Circumcision: Multicultural Perspectives (Pennsylvania Studies in Human Rights)
Liarienen
this book was used as a souce for a college report, very informative on difficult subject matter.
Shazel
Longtime Sudanese-American activist against female genital cutting (FGC) Rogaia Mustafa Abusharaf has edited Female Circumcision: Multicultural Perspectives. For better and for worse, this book exemplifies the strengths and weaknesses of edited volumes. Some contributions (those at the beginning and end of the book) are highly engaging and enlightening, while several of the middle chapters add little to the existing literature or to our understanding.

Things start off very promisingly indeed. Following a well-written if somewhat pro forma overview of the chapters to come written by editor Abusharaf, Egyptian-American anthropologist Fadwa El Guindi provides us with a fascinating, laudably free-thinking overview of FGC among Nubians in Egypt. El Guindi's title, "Had This Been Your Face, Would You Leave It As Is?" suggests her mission to re-examine practices in a manner as free of cultural biases as possible. Her extensive experience as an activist is evident. "Over forty years ago... [Charles] Callender and I argued for the significance of the notion of the cultural equivalence of male and female circumcision. [citation omitted] I argue now that this cultural equivalence extends analytically as a structural equivalence: that is, the two gendered rituals play equivalent roles in the transition of male and female children to adulthood... mark[ing] a transitional phase between birth and marriage."

El Guindi trenchantly notes that "Americans who express concern about female circumcision in other places do not campaign againstl [nose jobs, facelifts, and breast enlargement] with equal fervor despite the known health risks involved." Subsequently she expands on the analogy. "The phenomenon deceptively called `breast enhancement' could well be called `breast mutilation.' Culturally, it amounts to substituting men's sex pleasure in women's breasts for their maternal function." Accordingly: "Cross-cultural discussions about these matters should employ a single standard, not apply different standards to boys and girls or to Americans and Arabs or Africans."

El Guindi finds a lack of choice and a lack of ritual to be the two most pungent problems with MGC:
Choice is not brought up in relation to men who undergo very severe circumcision in various parts of the world, or the male babies in America who are operated on involuntarily. I find the cruelty of American male infant circumcision to lie in two dimensions: the absence of choice, and the absence of ritual. . . . Why do not activist feminists care about men's circumcision?

Their agenda is narrowly focused on women in Africa and the Middle East, who can be presented as inferior, less advanced, or more oppressed than Western women. . . Most interventionist debate. . . assumes that women in non-Western societies are childlike and helpless, passive victims of their men, who must be saved by Western missionaries and feminists. This stance is arrogant and ethnocentric.

El Guindi's conclusion is highly sympathetic to intactivism: "In considering circumcision, we must include male and female forms in the same discussion. . . "

In the chapter following this extremely promising start, intactivist Swiss-Palestinian academic Sami A. Aldeeb Abu-Sahlieh notes "a tendency to exaggerate the harmful sexual effects of female circumcision and to underestimate those of male circumcision." In the end, Aldeeb finds that it comes down to human rights. "The right to physical integrity is a principle. We must accept or reject genital cutting in totality. If we accept this principle, we must refrain from cutting of children's genitals regardless of their sex, their religion, or their culture." I found Aldeeb's contribution to include a rather more detailed review of religious doctrine than necessary, and yet one cannot help but welcome the perspective of the author of the excellent book Male and Female Circumcision Among Jews, Christians, and Muslims: Religious, Medical, Social and Legal Debate (Shangri-La Publications, 2001, previously reviewed in these pages).

Following this stellar beginning, we quickly and sharply decline in most of the chapters from the succeeding section on African programs to eradicate FGC. Asha Mohamud, Samson Radeny, and Karen Ringheim address "Community-Based Efforts to End FGC in Kenya." This triumvirate of authors clearly never met a male foreskin they liked, and are probably the record holders (no mean feat) for number of times blithely asserting the incomparability of MGC and FGC. Methinks they protest too much! Moreover, reading between the lines, they are evidently twisting their respondents' words to make them conform sufficiently with their feminist shibboleths.

The degree to which the three authors are weighted down with dogma is ironic, given that the two principal programs they are reviewing,o Maendeleo Ya Wanawake Organization (MYWO) and Program for Appropriate Technology in Health (PATH) have helped reduce FGC while remaining culturally sensitive and retaining a balanced perspective that permits ceremonial, non-mutilating rituals to continue. I also wonder why the three musketeers mention but fail to respond to "critics [who] questioned the priority given to eradicating FGM in light of other prevalent health problems, such as malaria." Most alarmingly, the authors assume that men (apparently by themselves) are forcing FGC upon girls to control their sexuality, whereas typically it tends to be mothers and grandmothers who are the primary continuers of the practice.

Amal Abdel Hadi tells a happier tale of Deir El Barsha, a Christian village in Egypt, which discontinued FGC in 1992 as a natural outgrowth of development efforts promoting women's participation and equality. The next two chapters, respectively by Nafissatou J. Diop and Ian Askew, and by Hamid El Bashir, are more conventional pieces that do little to advance the ongoing dialog about reconciling opposition to FGC with concerns about cultural imperialism. Shahira Ahmed's review of the work of Sudan's Babiker Badri Scientific Association for Women's Studies and the Eradication of Female Circumcision is even worse, uncritically parroting Muslim clerics' attempts to justify their opposition to FGC and their simultaneous support of MGC.

The next chapters improve greatly. Raqiya D. Abdalla, who nearly thirty years ago published the groundbreaking book on FGC, Sisters in Affliction, concludes the section on African anti-FGC programs by providing us with several moving, heart-rending first-person accounts by women who survived infibulations.

The final section, on debates in immigrant-receiving societies, is more even-handed and engaging. Audrey Macklin addresses attempts to use the criminal law to combat FGC in Canada, showing the potentially counterproductive outcomes of such overly paternalistic approaches. Intriguingly, she observes that the basis for outlawing MGC was actually stronger than for the action the Canadian government took in explicitly criminalizing FGC when the practice had already been pronounced illegal under existing laws against assault:

From a purely doctrinal perspective, it would have made more sense to create an exemption from the law of assault for male circumcision, a common cultural and religious practice in North America. . . The fact that no one seriously fears criminal prosecution for circumcising a male child speaks to the power of dominant cultural norms to supersede the letter of the law and determine what the law is "really" about.

After lengthy investigation, Macklin discovers, to her astonishment, that the primary impetus to criminalize FGC in Canada "emanated from women in immigrant communities who inserted themselves directly into the legislative process." Macklin contradicts herself on at least one point, stating on p. 216 that no one has ever been charged in Canada with an FGC-related offense, and then asserting four pages later that a Sudanese couple was charged in 2002 for performing genital cutting on their daughter.

Charles Piot checks in with a brief yet perceptive, provocative, and brave analysis of the Kasinga case in which US political asylum was granted to a Togolese woman based on her alleged fear of FGC. I could not help but notice that this appears to simply be an earlier version of his similar article in Bettina Shell-Duncan and Ylva Hernlund's superlative 2007 edited volume Transcultural Bodies: Female Genital Cutting in Global Context (also reviewed in these pages). Nevertheless, Piot is so good at what he does that I enjoyed reading again his even-handed review of this woman's fraud-filled story and of the systemic biases and crude anti-African prejudice (among the court and the public alike) that contributed to her eventual victory.
The unfailingly brilliant Nigerian-American scholar L. Amede Obiora concludes the book with an afterword ostensibly reviewing and integrating the volume's contributions. Much as I enjoy Obiora's writing and her commitment to FGC scholarship that is free of groupthink and committed to balancing culture and rights, I was disappointed by her failure to even mention Sami Aldeeb's contribution to Female Circumcision. Despite the engaging and varying grappling with MGC in which several contributors participated, Obiora focuses exclusively on FGC.

Female Circumcision: Multicultural Perspectives ends up as bit of a mixed bag, but a reasonably-priced book whose opening and concluding chapters amply repay the reader's attention and financial outlay. Recommended.
Related to Female Circumcision: Multicultural Perspectives (Pennsylvania Studies in Human Rights)
Genital Cutting and Transnational Sisterhood: Disputing U.S. Polemics eBook
Fb2 Genital Cutting and Transnational Sisterhood: Disputing U.S. Polemics ePub
Human Rights in African Prisons (Research in International Studies) eBook
Fb2 Human Rights in African Prisons (Research in International Studies) ePub
Human Rights NGOs in East Africa: Political and Normative Tensions (Pennsylvania Studies in Human Rights) eBook
Fb2 Human Rights NGOs in East Africa: Political and Normative Tensions (Pennsylvania Studies in Human Rights) ePub
Engendering Human Rights: Cultural and Socio-Economic Realities in Africa (Comparative Feminist Studies) eBook
Fb2 Engendering Human Rights: Cultural and Socio-Economic Realities in Africa (Comparative Feminist Studies) ePub
Circumcision What Every Parent Should Know eBook
Fb2 Circumcision What Every Parent Should Know ePub
Circumcision Exposed: Rethinking a Medical and Cultural Tradition eBook
Fb2 Circumcision Exposed: Rethinking a Medical and Cultural Tradition ePub
Is There a God of Human Rights? The Complex Relationship Between Human Rights and Religion, a South African... (International Studies in Religion and Society, 2) eBook
Fb2 Is There a God of Human Rights? The Complex Relationship Between Human Rights and Religion, a South African... (International Studies in Religion and Society, 2) ePub
Women, Law and Human Rights: An African Perspective eBook
Fb2 Women, Law and Human Rights: An African Perspective ePub
Circumcision: A History of the World's Most Controversial Surgery eBook
Fb2 Circumcision: A History of the World's Most Controversial Surgery ePub